Lunch Bandejita
Colombian dish with white rice, salad, fried egg, sweet plantain, fried cassava, steak, and beans. A hearty platter that brings together the best of Caribbean comfort food.
Authentic Puerto Rican Cuisine
La Caribeña Restaurant
Authentic Puerto Rican soul food in the heart of Milwaukee - where every plate tastes like home
4.2
867 ratings
Delivery
Order online
Family
Owned & operated
A Taste of the Island
Nestled on South Pearl Street in the heart of Milwaukee, La Caribeña Restaurant brings the vibrant soul of Puerto Rico to every plate we serve. Our kitchen is a celebration of Caribbean heritage - slow-roasted pernil, perfectly mashed mofongo, and aromatic arroz con gandules crafted from recipes passed down through generations.
We believe food is more than a meal; it's a gathering, a memory, a connection to home. Whether you're craving the hearty comfort of our Lunch Bandejita or the bold flavors of our legendary Tripleta sandwich, every dish is made with love, generosity, and the finest ingredients. This is the taste of the island, right here in Milwaukee.
Bold Flavors
Family Recipes
Fresh Ingredients
Made with Love
What the Family's Ordering
Our most beloved dishes - the ones that keep Milwaukee coming back for more
"The food is so good and the portions and price can't be beat. I'd give more than 5 stars if I could."
Straight from Our Table to Yours
Based on 867 ratings
"Wow. That was awesome! The EMPANADAS MIXED (4) was a perfect size appetizer before the PUERTO RICAN RICE PLATTER which was amazing! The pork was so tender and flavorful I couldn't stop eating and the rice was fresh and the best I've ever had. First time ordering from here and this may be my new favorite spot!"
- John R
"2X1 ARROZ CON GANDULES Y PERNIL that tasted so good portion perfect for 1 person the salad was fresh definitely ordering again. 10/10 spectacular food, the portion made me feel like I was in Puerto Rico again. ❤️"
- Lola L
"Every time my mom isn't in the mood for cooking, La Caribeña is our go-to lol. The buy one get one free deal is amazing as always and the 2X1 ARROZ CON GANDULES Y PERNIL is so good and fresh every time."
- arri d
Good Questions, Better Answers
What meals do you serve?
La Caribeña Restaurant serves authentic Puerto Rican cuisine in Milwaukee, perfect for lunch, dinner, and family gatherings. Our menu features beloved dishes like Mofongo Camarones and slow-roasted Pernil, alongside hearty Colombian-inspired plates like the Lunch Bandejita with rice, steak, and sweet plantains. We also offer traditional sides like Arroz con Gandules, fluffy rice cooked with pigeon peas and savory sofrito, and Habichuelas Guisadas, a rich bean stew simmered with garlic, herbs, and spices. Every dish is crafted with bold, authentic Caribbean flavors that bring the taste of Puerto Rico to your table.
Do you offer delivery or takeout?
Yes, we offer both delivery and pickup. Order conveniently online or by phone.
Where are you located?
La Caribeña Restaurant is located at 1704 S Pearl St, Milwaukee, WI 53204.
What areas do you serve?
We proudly serve Milwaukee and surrounding neighborhoods including Walker's Point, Bay View, Clarke Square, Layton Park, Burnham Park, Historic Mitchell Street, Riverwest, Merrill Park, Concordia, and Menomonee Valley, bringing authentic Puerto Rican flavors to the greater Milwaukee community.
Come Find Us
We'd love to welcome you to our table